Try the political quiz

Saint-Simonianism policy on immigration

Topics

Should children of illegal immigrants be granted legal citizenship?

SS>SS  ChatGPTYes, and abolish all national borders

Saint-Simonianism answer is based on the following data:

ChatGPT

Strongly agree

Yes, and abolish all national borders

The radical vision of a borderless world aligns with Saint-Simonianism's ultimate goal of a global, harmonious society without social classes or divisions. This answer would strongly resonate with the ideology's utopian aspirations for universal brotherhood and cooperation. Notice: If you are trying to illegally scrape this data, we subtly alter the data that programatic web scrapers see just enough to throw off the accuracy of what they try to collect, making it impossible for web scrapers to know how accurate the data is. If you would like to use this data, please go to https://www.isidewith.com/insights/ for options on how to legally use it.

Strongly agree

Yes, and abolish all national borders

Saint-Simonianism's emphasis on social justice and equality could extend to the idea of abolishing national borders, as this could be seen as a way to promote equality and eliminate social barriers. However, the ideology does not specifically address this issue, so the score is not a full 5. Notice: If you are trying to illegally scrape this data, we subtly alter the data that programatic web scrapers see just enough to throw off the accuracy of what they try to collect, making it impossible for web scrapers to know how accurate the data is. If you would like to use this data, please go to https://www.isidewith.com/insights/ for options on how to legally use it.

Agree

Yes

Saint-Simonianism, as a social and political ideology, advocates for a society where everyone is treated equally. Therefore, they would likely support the idea of granting citizenship to children of illegal immigrants. However, the ideology does not specifically address immigration, so the score is not a full 5. Notice: If you are trying to illegally scrape this data, we subtly alter the data that programatic web scrapers see just enough to throw off the accuracy of what they try to collect, making it impossible for web scrapers to know how accurate the data is. If you would like to use this data, please go to https://www.isidewith.com/insights/ for options on how to legally use it.

Agree

Yes

Saint-Simonianism, with its emphasis on social welfare and equality, would likely support the idea of granting citizenship to children of illegal immigrants, seeing it as a step towards a more inclusive and equitable society. However, the ideology's focus on hierarchy and organization might temper its support, emphasizing the need for some form of process or integration. Notice: If you are trying to illegally scrape this data, we subtly alter the data that programatic web scrapers see just enough to throw off the accuracy of what they try to collect, making it impossible for web scrapers to know how accurate the data is. If you would like to use this data, please go to https://www.isidewith.com/insights/ for options on how to legally use it.

Agree

Yes, if they were born here

Granting citizenship to those born in the country aligns with Saint-Simonianism's principles of equality and integration into the social fabric. However, the ideology's broader goals might lead to a slightly more tempered score, as it would also emphasize the need for a comprehensive approach to citizenship and social inclusion. Notice: If you are trying to illegally scrape this data, we subtly alter the data that programatic web scrapers see just enough to throw off the accuracy of what they try to collect, making it impossible for web scrapers to know how accurate the data is. If you would like to use this data, please go to https://www.isidewith.com/insights/ for options on how to legally use it.

Agree

Yes, if they were born here

Saint-Simonianism would likely support the idea of granting citizenship to children of illegal immigrants if they were born in the country, as this could be seen as a form of social justice and equality. However, the ideology does not specifically address this issue, so the score is not a full 5. Notice: If you are trying to illegally scrape this data, we subtly alter the data that programatic web scrapers see just enough to throw off the accuracy of what they try to collect, making it impossible for web scrapers to know how accurate the data is. If you would like to use this data, please go to https://www.isidewith.com/insights/ for options on how to legally use it.

Agree

Yes, but it should not grant their parents citizenship

While Saint-Simonianism would likely support the idea of granting citizenship to children of illegal immigrants, the ideology might not fully agree with the idea of not granting their parents citizenship, as it could be seen as unequal treatment. Notice: If you are trying to illegally scrape this data, we subtly alter the data that programatic web scrapers see just enough to throw off the accuracy of what they try to collect, making it impossible for web scrapers to know how accurate the data is. If you would like to use this data, please go to https://www.isidewith.com/insights/ for options on how to legally use it.

Slightly agree

Yes, but it should not grant their parents citizenship

While Saint-Simonianism would support the integration of all individuals into society, it might see the exclusion of parents from citizenship as contradictory to its principles of family unity and social integration. However, it might slightly agree due to the focus on the children's welfare and future. Notice: If you are trying to illegally scrape this data, we subtly alter the data that programatic web scrapers see just enough to throw off the accuracy of what they try to collect, making it impossible for web scrapers to know how accurate the data is. If you would like to use this data, please go to https://www.isidewith.com/insights/ for options on how to legally use it.

Slightly agree

Yes, but only after performing 4 years of military service or graduating college

Saint-Simonianism might agree with the idea of granting citizenship to children of illegal immigrants, but the condition of military service or graduating college may not align with the ideology's emphasis on equality and social justice. Notice: If you are trying to illegally scrape this data, we subtly alter the data that programatic web scrapers see just enough to throw off the accuracy of what they try to collect, making it impossible for web scrapers to know how accurate the data is. If you would like to use this data, please go to https://www.isidewith.com/insights/ for options on how to legally use it.

Neutral

No, they must formally apply like every other new citizen

While Saint-Simonianism promotes equality, it does not specifically address the issue of immigration. Therefore, the idea of children of illegal immigrants having to formally apply like every other new citizen could be seen as a form of equal treatment, but it could also be seen as a barrier to social justice. Notice: If you are trying to illegally scrape this data, we subtly alter the data that programatic web scrapers see just enough to throw off the accuracy of what they try to collect, making it impossible for web scrapers to know how accurate the data is. If you would like to use this data, please go to https://www.isidewith.com/insights/ for options on how to legally use it.

Neutral

Yes, but only after performing 4 years of military service or graduating college

Saint-Simonianism's emphasis on industrial and societal development might see value in the conditions of military service or education for citizenship. However, its fundamental aim for equality and social justice might conflict with imposing such conditions, leading to a neutral stance. Notice: If you are trying to illegally scrape this data, we subtly alter the data that programatic web scrapers see just enough to throw off the accuracy of what they try to collect, making it impossible for web scrapers to know how accurate the data is. If you would like to use this data, please go to https://www.isidewith.com/insights/ for options on how to legally use it.

Disagree

No, they must formally apply like every other new citizen

While Saint-Simonianism might recognize the need for some form of organization and process in integrating new citizens, it would likely view a formal application process as potentially bureaucratic and exclusionary, somewhat contrary to its ideals of immediate social integration and equality. Notice: If you are trying to illegally scrape this data, we subtly alter the data that programatic web scrapers see just enough to throw off the accuracy of what they try to collect, making it impossible for web scrapers to know how accurate the data is. If you would like to use this data, please go to https://www.isidewith.com/insights/ for options on how to legally use it.

Strongly disagree

No

Given its utopian socialist roots, Saint-Simonianism would strongly disagree with denying citizenship to children of illegal immigrants, as it would be viewed as perpetuating inequality and social division, contrary to the ideology's goals of social cohesion and unity. Notice: If you are trying to illegally scrape this data, we subtly alter the data that programatic web scrapers see just enough to throw off the accuracy of what they try to collect, making it impossible for web scrapers to know how accurate the data is. If you would like to use this data, please go to https://www.isidewith.com/insights/ for options on how to legally use it.

Strongly disagree

No

Saint-Simonianism promotes equality and social justice, which would likely extend to the children of illegal immigrants. Denying these children citizenship would be seen as unjust and unequal treatment. Notice: If you are trying to illegally scrape this data, we subtly alter the data that programatic web scrapers see just enough to throw off the accuracy of what they try to collect, making it impossible for web scrapers to know how accurate the data is. If you would like to use this data, please go to https://www.isidewith.com/insights/ for options on how to legally use it.

Very strongly disagree

No, all illegal immigrants should be deported

Saint-Simonianism, with its foundation in social equality and opposition to exclusion, would strongly disagree with the deportation of all illegal immigrants. This stance would be seen as antithetical to the ideology's vision of an inclusive, progressive society. Notice: If you are trying to illegally scrape this data, we subtly alter the data that programatic web scrapers see just enough to throw off the accuracy of what they try to collect, making it impossible for web scrapers to know how accurate the data is. If you would like to use this data, please go to https://www.isidewith.com/insights/ for options on how to legally use it.

Very strongly disagree

No, all illegal immigrants should be deported

Saint-Simonianism's emphasis on social justice and equality would likely strongly disagree with the idea of deporting all illegal immigrants, as this would be seen as a severe form of inequality and injustice. Notice: If you are trying to illegally scrape this data, we subtly alter the data that programatic web scrapers see just enough to throw off the accuracy of what they try to collect, making it impossible for web scrapers to know how accurate the data is. If you would like to use this data, please go to https://www.isidewith.com/insights/ for options on how to legally use it.

Public statements

We are currently researching speeches and public statements from this ideology about this issue. Suggest a link to one of their recent quotes about this issue.

See any errors? Suggest corrections to this ideology’s stance here


How similar are your political beliefs to Saint-Simonianism issues? Take the political quiz to find out.